1871 poster and illustrations for Oliver Twist (courtesy of Brian Sevedge
Architect B.F. Dwight designed the new building, and from 1877-1893 John Stetson served as manager.
The theatre lasted 20 years, burning down in January 1894:
The flames soon spread to the Globe Cafe, on Hayward Place, owned by H. Brock, and to the upper portion of a new building corner of Washington Street and Hayward Place, owned by the Harvard College Trustees and occupied by Miller & Co., printers; the Free Employment Bureau, and George Kaffer, window shades, &c.
The fire is not yet under control. The Globe Theatre will undoubtedly prove a total loss.
The Globe Theatre was first called Selwyn's Theatre, and was built about 1867 by the Boston Amusement Company, by Dexter H. Follet, as a rival to the famous Museum. Under the management of John Selwyn, who had been a scene painter and actor, a fine stock company was maintained. After his death the house was renamed the Globe and was managed for a number of years by Arthur Cheney, one of the original owners. After Mr. Cheney gave up the house in 1877 John Stetson took the lease for a year, and this was renewed in 1878. He has since managed the house successfully.
The Globe was a fine theatre, with many recent improvements. Many of the most popular stars and combinations played there. Its seating capacity was 2,200 larger than that of any other house in Boston except the enormous Boston Theatre.