Herald Square Theatre

corner of Broadway and 35th Street / NYC

("New Park" Theatre / 1883-1894)

Built in 1883 at the corner of Broadway and 35th Street as the New Park Theatre (where the New York Aquarium formerly stood)
the New Park was almost entirely rebuilt eleven years later for actor/producer Charles Evans, who had it renamed the
Herald Square Theatre, opening with the American premiere of George Bernard Shaw’s Arms and the Man in 1894.

The Herald Square was not notable for its appearance, which both inside and out was rather plain and unadorned compared to later Broadway houses, though Evans did have a graceful red marble colonnade erected along the Broadway facade, while the remainder of the exterior was in tan brick in the Italianate style. Its signage was also fairly simple, consisting of a large rooftop sign, and an inscribed sign under the cornice.

However, the theater was notable for several other things: it was the first New York theater leased by the Shuberts
(starting in 1900), it was the theater at which stage legend Helen Hayes made her Broadway debut, at age nine, in 1909
(a year after the Herald Square was gutted by a blaze and rebuilt as a smaller house), and it was the first legitimate
Broadway theater to be converted into a movie house, in 1912, under Marcus Loew. Its career as a movie theater was brief --
the Herald Square Theatre was closed in 1914 and demolished in 1920 to make way for an office building.

Herald Square Today

Programs available from this theatre:

  • 3 Twins / 1908

  • Return to Index of Theatres